Meet the opposition: Crystal palace
It has been a topsy-turvy season for the Eagles, but they have held their own in recent meetings
Although Bruno Fernandes is the star of the front cover and our lead article this issue, it could almost be considered a Fred special, with both Ayantan Chowdhury and Derick Kinoti taking a look at Ten Hag’s latest miracle do-over. Ayantan looks at the Ten Hag effect and how he has transformed the Brazilian, which leads Derick to ask whether there is now a clear future for him at Old Trafford.
Another player whose future needs to be decided soon is Anthony Martial. The Frenchman always divides fans, with some clinging on to the Jekyll side of his mercurial nature while others see only Hyde. Inconsistency must now officially be paired with injury-proneness, so is it time to cash in and move on? Or can the manager find a way to bring out the best in him as well? Red Moon and Red Billy argue this one in the Devils’ Advocate.
Ten Hag is not the only United manager to be transforming his side into title contenders. Marc Skinner has got the women firing as well. Wins against Arsenal and a 6-0 drubbing of Liverpool on Sunday have sent the Barmy Army into meltdown and this time, there is a belief that United could be just a couple of good signings away from a historic season. Who they might be is revealed by Zoe Hodges in her column.
But back to Bruno Fernandes, our cover star. He is thriving in his de facto captaincy and match by match seems to be coming back to the kind of form that he showed when he first joined United. One of the biggest problems the Reds have had in recent years is that there have been too many inconsistent players in their ranks – world class one day, and bang average the next. We’ve mentioned Martial and Fred there, Marcus Rashford and Jadon Sancho are arguably in that category as well, as is Bruno. If Ten Hag and his staff are able to get that group to up their consistency, United suddenly really do look like title contenders, and Fernandes is perhaps the most vital cog of all in that particular wheel.
Three points against Palace will make it ten on the bounce for United, but it won’t come easy. Ten Hag’s men are starting to look a bit like the walking wounded and with games coming thick and fast, there’s little respite. We’re hoping and expecting Wout Weghorst to make his debut in this one and fingers crossed he hits the ground running. That will really take the pressure off the likes of Martial and Rashford and give us a real boost on this frenetic run-in.
Let’s do this!
powered by
Erik ten Hag reserved special praise for his de facto captain after the derby, with good reason
Erik Ten Hag was rightfully effusive when praising his team in the aftermath of yesterday’s thrilling Manchester Derby. ‘I think all my players were brilliant’ the Dutchman declared, encapsulating an impressive team performance, and well-deserved win, against a Manchester City side who ran riot in the reverse fixture earlier in the season. It was a controlled performance which maximised United’s strengths and restricted City’s, starving their forwards of meaningful chances and opportunities.
Pep Guardiola’s team maintained 71% possession of the ball yet only managed one shot on target all game. United, by contrast, converted their 29% possession into four shots on target; the xG – United (2.07)-City (0.76) – reflected the control, without the ball, Ten Hag’s team were able to exert on proceedings. City were possession without intention; United defensively sound with ruthless transitions. Guardiola confirmed this assessment in his post-match interview, describing United as an ‘incredible threat in the transitions and the counter attack’.
While it was a team effort, at the heart of this domination of the transition was undoubtedly Manchester United’s enigmatic midfielder, Bruno Fernandes. Ten Hag, in the same breath as the universal praise for his team, chose to individually praise his on the field leader: ‘I definitely have to mention Bruno, he was really brilliant’. In a match where every United player constituted brilliant, what made Bruno Fernandes’ performance really brilliant?
A question with many possible answers, but the most accurate would be the Portuguese midfielder produced a quintessential captain’s performance. He demonstrated the type of attitude and leadership Old Trafford has been starved of in the ignominy of recent years, as well as the tactical intelligence and work rate to help Ten Hag successfully implement his game plan. All while sacrificing his usual position and natural inclinations with the ball. Bruno wore the arm band the way a derby demands you wear it.
Relocated to the right-wing to enable Ten Hag to buttress the midfield, Fernandes can feel like an awkward fit in the position. Lacking the acceleration or sleight of feet associated with more natural wide players, as well as being consigned to the wing which does not allow him to cut in on his favoured right foot, Fernandes does not allow such limitations to affect his attitude or application. He pressed intensely and intelligently; he diligently tracked the runs of his compatriot João Cancelo and helped Wan-Bissaka double up on Foden; he filled in centrally when the midfield was threatened; and he utilised the ball productively, particularly in transitions.
The positional sacrifice of Fernandes also gave room in the starting eleven for Fred, tasked with man-marking Kevin De Bruyne, where the Brazilian was especially effective in the first-half. Furthermore, it pushed Christian Eriksen forward, into Bruno’s normal home, where he helped to apply constant pressure to Rodri, as well as knitting together counter-attacks with simple, but adroit, use of the ball. The team was far more balanced as a result, compared to the one which was metaphorically maimed at the Etihad, and the contrast in performances (and score lines) reflected this. The positional sacrifice of Fernandes was the catalyst behind this tactical equilibrium.
But where attitude and work-rate are the foundations of a good performance, it’s skill and intelligence which elevate it to a great one. In a match where the tactical instruction is primarily one of defensive solidity, deliberately ceding possession of the ball for control of the game, a team’s ability to counter-attack effectively is paramount. Fernandes was decisive in these moments, clinically scoring the equaliser, with the help of a dubious interpretation of the offside rule, before providing the penetrating pass to Alejandro Garnacho, who assisted Marcus Rashford for the winner. Four minutes, two transitions, two goals.
On display in both attacks was this requisite combination of skill and intelligence, particularly in the first. The through-ball to Garnacho was superb but the equaliser demonstrated the combination of talents Fernandes brings to the table. It was, firstly, a brilliant finish, curled round Ederson with pace and precision at a crucial moment in the game. The intelligence and awareness, however, to instruct Rashford to not touch the ball having known the winger was offside, and instead using him as a quasi-offensive lineman, while simultaneously producing a finish of that quality, is really brilliant.
There was a moment immediately following the goal where it seemed it would be disallowed however. Rashford was clearly offside and the decision appeared inevitable. Fernandes was immediately on to the linesman, berating him with a barrage of protestations and explanations for why it should stand. It’s an attitude that footballing purists may disagree with but one that is undeniably effective. There was also a moment late in the game, with City seeking to ramp up the pressure, where Fernandes went down holding his leg, demanding the referee stop play. The legitimacy of the ‘injury’ is doubtful but what is undoubted was the effectiveness with which it helped break up the rhythm the opposition were seeking to establish.
The ‘Dark Arts’ represent a murky area in which there exists a reluctance to compliment a player’s proficiency at wielding their powers. It’s a form of footballing intelligence, however, which can be a necessary evil at times. Fernandes has a feel for this this side of football in a way that someone like Harry Maguire does not. Having a captain adept at this style of in-game management can be invaluable for a manager; particularly when they combine it with the skill Fernandes possesses.
The goal took Fernandes’ tally in the league since his debut to 39 – no other midfielder has scored more in this time. His performance more generally also earned him the Man of the Match award – no other United player has achieved more since his debut. During the interview for the presention of the award Fernandes was keen, however, to stress the importance of the collective over the individual:
‘I said it before the game to the team…we look like a team now. Some months ago, you could see that [we were] sometimes a times, sometimes looking out for ourselves. Now you see a proper team that works hard for each other and you can see that it pays.’
They’re words which echo sentiments Ten Hag has consistently sought to stress as integral in his interviews. The voice of a captain who is the extension of his manager, on and off the pitch. When this attitude and leadership is combined with Fernandes’ skill and intelligence, it’s a brilliant combination.
Manchester United fans certainly have fond memories of a former midfield general in Bryan Robson, who earned the nickname ‘Captain Marvel.’ In Bruno Fernandes they have a current midfield maverick who could be nicknamed ‘Captain Brilliant’ – or ‘Captain Really Brilliant’ if left up to his manager.
Darragh Fox
It has been a topsy-turvy season for the Eagles, but they have held their own in recent meetings

The former Arsenal legend has enjoyed a mixed time as Eagles boss. There have been memorable performances including their run to the FA Cup semifinals last season and their wins against Manchester United as well as City. But it has proved to be tougher in his second season with an early exit in the FA Cup as well as disappointing results in the league including against Everton and Nottingham Forest. He has overseen a shift in the team's playing style -- from a reactive defence-oriented approach under Roy Hodgson to a more possession-based attacking mindset.

With three goals and three assists in 17 league appearances so far this season, Eberechi Eze has again proved to be crucial cog in Patrick Vieira's Crystal Palace side. The 24-year-old had started the season slowly, with just two assists in his first seven outings. But from the 10th week onwards, he has improved his goal threat by leaps and bounds. His total of 23 shots and 22 chances created are both more than any team-mate over Palace’s last 10 matches. Eze's direct nature and fearless playing style leaves many defenders on their heels and it will be no different when United visit Selhurst Park.

Crystal Palace have been a consistent mid-table team, always finishing in and around the same position and have always given the big guns a hard time on more than a few occasions. However, under Patrick Vieira, fans were hoping for more consistency. There have been complaints from some fans about the French manager being too rigid in his formation and playing players out of position, but the manager believes he has the answer to that conundrum: the January transfer window. But club chairman Steve Parish has already advised that Palace will be more likely to look at loan signings than anyone permanent.

Zaha will remain Sir Alex Ferguson's parting gift as Manchester United manager, having signed him before retiring from his post. For one reason or the other, Zaha's time as a Red Devils came to a disappointing end. But he has been Palace's best player since he re-signed for the London outfit. Zaha enjoyed his most prolific campaign as an Eagles star last season under Vieira. He has once again been their talisman this current current campaign with his total of six goals being at least double that of any other Palace player. The underlying numbers further highlight Zaha’s influence on the Eagles' attack. His 35 shots, 26 shots in the box, eight big chances and 15 shots on target all rank top for Vieira’s side.

Despite indifferent form heading into the contest, it is worth remembering that Palace beat United 1-0 in the same fixture last season, a game Erik ten Hag ended up attending. The Eagles have proved to be some sort of bogey team in recent seasons, with United losing three of their last six games against the team from London. But before these last six games, it had taken Palace 31 games to win the same number of contests, such was United's dominance. But United have never lost consecutive games against them. Crystal Palace are now approaching the midway point in their Premier League season and disappointingly, they have failed to win more than two straight games.

Palace will enter the game against United in poor form. They have lost three games on the bounce in all competitions, not the ideal preparations ahead of such a big game. In fact, their poor run has started since domestic football resumed post the World Cup break. They have lost all but one game since the World Cup but due to their bright start to the season. they possess enough of a cushion not to be too worried about a relegation scrap as of now. However, major problems loom across the horizon. Ten players will be out of contract next summer and the Palace owners do not have several hundred million to spend in one window to alleviate those issues.
Wout Weghorst could be pressed into action early for Manchester United on Wednesday as injuries to Anthony Martial and Marcus Rashford have made them doubtful for the Palace match.
Martial was touch and go to make the City match and was subbed at half time after looking less than fit. Rashford had gone down injured before half time and looked as if it would be he who was substituted, but he played on with a hip injury and was instrumental in both United’s comeback goals in the second half. Sorry, he wasn’t at all instrumental in Bruno Fernandes’ goal, what were we thinking? But with a huge match against Arsenal coming up at the weekend, he could and probably should be rested against Palace to allow his painful hip time to recover.
This all leaves Weghorst, a loanee arrival from Burnley, the most likely to start up front, with either or both Rashford and Martial available from the bench if needed.
The debutant is likely to be flanked by Antony and Alejandro Garnacho unless Jadon Sancho, who was spotted signing autographs at Old Trafford on Saturday, is available to return. Anthony Elanga is another option but has been in poor form.
Selhurst Park is a difficult venue, so Erik Ten Hag cannot afford to make too many changes but there are players who will almost certainly need to be rested. Christian Eriksen was ineffective in the number 10 role against City, so Bruno Fernandes is likely to reprise his normal role, especially as he got a rest last Wednesday due to suspension. We think with Arsenal in mind, Eriksen may be rested against Palace, with the in-form Fred keeping his place in the side alongside Casemiro in defensive midfield.
Luke Shaw has been in superb form and could also be put in cotton wool, as could the injury-prone Raphael Varane, so the centre-back pairing of Harry Maguire and Lisandro Martinez that kept a clean sheet against Charlton last week could be restored. Diogo Dalot is another injury doubt and so Aaron Wan-Bissaka, who is also in incredible form, could keep his place.
There is no reason to doubt that David de Gea will continue in goal.
Referee: John Brooks.
Assistants: Adam Nunn, Nick Hopton.
Fourth official: Stuart Attwell.
VAR: Neil Swarbrick. Assistant VAR: Neil Davies.
Manchester United had started the season under new manager Erik ten Hag in really poor fashion, losing two on the bounce in the Premier League as well as the opener in the Europa League. And quite a few players were guilty of putting in disappointing performances in those games, most notably Fred.
The Brazilian has always been a divisive figure since his £52m move back in 2018. While there have been the occasional bright sparks, his general play has not been up to the standards fans have come to expect from a United midfielder. Some of it has not been his fault. With the Glazers’ failure to address the need to bring in a proper defensive midfielder, Fred had to be paired up with Scott McTominay to bring some sort of balance to the squad. And the quality levels dropped massively, with both not bringing much in terms of creativity.
But as football fans around the world had seen, the 29-year-old never faced these questions while playing for his home country due to the presence of Casemiro. And as luck would have it, the multiple Champions League winner decided to make the move to Old Trafford and thus, Fred finally got the perfect partner to show off what he is capable of.
Ten Hag tried to play him higher up the pitch against Real Sociedad, but once again, his skill-set does not involve him creating too much due to his sometimes erratic passing. But since the World Cup break, United’s Dutch mastermind has found the perfect role for the Brazil international.
He has been introduced late on in games, with United requiring more energy to get a goal. And he has delivered and how. From a goal against Nottingham Forest to a vital contribution for Marcus Rashford to grab the winner against Wolves, Fred has played his part to perfection.
That is because what Fred brings to the table is relentless pressing, non-stop running and the ability to pop up where he is required. Something, his coaches in the Brazilian set-up have referenced time and again. And Ten Hag was full of praise for the kind of impact he had off the bench. “We emphasise a lot of times that we’ve often had players who score goals when they come on from the bench, like Fred did last week,” Ten Hag told club media.
“Every time when he’s coming on, he’s ready. He’s front foot and he brings the right quality to the game. That is great to have that as a team and as a manager. Of course, Fred wants to play every game but we need those players coming from the bench and giving impact to the game. Definitely, Fred is the one – there are others as well, but Fred is the example.”
Against opposition where there is no need to play as cautiously or against teams who have a tendency of being reliant on ball possession, Ten Hag has invariably turned to Fred. Despite playing only 60 minutes, Fred put in one of his best displays of the season against Charlton Athletic in the Carabao Cup quarterfinals.
His performance saw him being named in the Team of the Round along with two-goal hero Rashford. For naysayers who think it was easy considering their League One status, Ten Hag has opted to use the Brazilian in games against Chelsea, Newcastle United and Tottenham Hotspur.
And against Manchester City in the Manchester derby, his performance was reminiscent of the kind of displays put in by Sir Alex Ferguson’s trusted lieutenants, who did not play as much but came alive during the big occasions. His display on Saturday was akin to the ones put in by Darren Fletcher against much more superior opposition, Ji-Sung Park’s famous man-marking job on Andrea Pirlo to the more recent display put in by Ander Herrera against Eden Hazard of Chelsea.
His involvement was necessary considering Christian Eriksen got overrun last time around. And once again, he was immense, popping up everywhere across the pitch. That in itself is vindication of the turnaround in Fred‘s form this season. From being ridiculed to being one of the stars in the biggest games, he has come a long way.
There are still rumours that he might be sacrificed in the next transfer window for someone of more quality but having a character like Fred in the dressing room, who does not complain and gives his all in every game is an asset worth having. In Ten Hag we trust and he will have the final call on Fred‘s contract, which is set to end in 2024. But the Dutchman seems to trust Fred and that is proof enough of his importance.
Ayantan Chowdhury
In this section we look at some of the most active transfer stories of the week about United, both comings and goings. We give each story a fire rating (how hot the story is, out of five) and a star rating (how reliable the story is, out of five).
🔥🔥🔥🔥
The Toffees are very keen on a loan for Elanga and there is even talk of a permanent deal. They desperately need something to turn their season around. Facundo Pellistri could step into his shoes at United, and the club needs funds, so this could be a genuine possibility, although the tier 1 reporters are not getting to excited about it yet.
🔥🔥
Showdown talks are taking place with Pellistri’s agent about the next six months as clubs such as Bologna and Botafogo line up to avail themselves of his services. The latest reports claim United want to keep him at Old Trafford. It could come down to a simple choice between him and Elanga: one stays, one goes.
Chelsea, Newcastle, Inter Milan, Atletico Madrid and Aston Villa are all keen on the 23 year old, with the Blues reportedly in the driving seat.
Inter were leading the chase for him but a €15m fee and €5m salary is deemed out of their reach. La Repubbica claimed in December that the Red Devils had already made a contract offer. But either that was rejected or untrue as Weghorst wouldn’t have been signed if it was still a possibility for this month. June, still possible.
🔥
This is another one that looks far less likely now United have signed Wout Weghorst, but Ten Hag could surprise us and has confirmed that he is still looking for signings this month.
Fabrizio Romano is now reporting that Memphis is almost certain to leave Barça this month, but the odds of that being to United are much longer than they were.
🔥
The 18-year-old’s contract at Dortmund expires in June and his agent has said they are not close to agreeing a new deal, although Sport in Spain claim that he might now be considering it if the buyout clause has a cheap option for certain clubs, including Barcelona.
If he is a free agent in the summer, Barca are favourites, especially if Chelsea sign Thuram. But Dortmund might be persuaded to cash out now if United can raise a few bob. Rumours also this week that he is really 22 and not 18 might muddy the waters on this one.
🔥🔥🔥
After a good start to the season, McTominay has found himself well down the pecking order at Old Trafford, alerting a number of Premier League clubs, including Southampton, Leeds, Everton, West Ham, Leicester and Newcastle, who have all reportedly made enquiries.
They have been told hands off for January, which is almost a given due to United’s depleted squad, but a summer move could be on the cards.
Getty Images
Fred may have already earned a new long-term contract at United
As Manchester United staged a brilliant fightback against their city neighbours on derby day to clinch all three points, there was an unlikely hero in the side – Fred. While the Brazilian did not get on the scoresheet, register an assist or execute any flare action that would get tongues wagging on a compilation reel, it would not be a stretch to say that United would have probably not run out winners against Manchester City without Fred’s input. He was immense from the first whistle until the final second of the hotly-contested affair. A surprise inclusion in the starting XI after weeks of being relegated to the bench and primarily coming on as an impact substitute, Fred repaid Erik ten Hag’s faith in kind and more than vindicated the Dutchman’s decision to drop Antony in favour of him.
In the opening 45 minutes especially, Fred came up with a monster performance that saw the Red Devils dominate their supposedly vastly superior rivals in ways not seen since Sir Alex Ferguson’s retirement. The 29-year-old injected incredible amounts of energy into the middle of the park and ensured it was packed to the brim in an effort to close down the spaces between the lines. The midfielder was tasked with patrolling the dangerous Kevin de Bruyne and he excelled at this to great effect. He stuck to the Belgian like glue and barely gave him time to breathe. The result is that for large parts of the first half, De Bruyne, City’s primary source of creativity and inspiration in front of goal was rendered neutral and ineffective. Fred was delicately balanced in his aggressive tackling, interceptions and all other defensive actions. His passing, something that has been used as a beating stick against him during his time so far at Old Trafford, was nothing short of exquisite. He barely put a foot wrong – something that extended well into the second half and gave United a solid foundation from which they mustered the sensational comeback.
Even in games before the derby, Fred has been superb. He started against Charlton and starred in a much-changed team, even coming close to finding the back of the net with a wonderful free-kick. He came on against Everton, Bournemouth and Wolves and was equally impactful. In the 3-0 win against Nottingham Forest, he was substituted on and grabbed a goal to seal United’s victory against Steve Cooper’s men.
During his tenure at United, there are not many players who have divided the fanbase and elicited mixed reactions as much as Fred. He boasts of the staunchest of supporters and the harshest of critics. This is largely due to the erratic nature of his gameplay and performances. When playing well, Fred is an unplayable operator and few can match him on the pitch. However, when poor, his displays can be mistaken for sabotage at times considering the amateur flaws that punctuate them to the extent that even a simple pass looks difficult for him. That has been the story of Fred so far in a United shirt.
However, under Ten Hag, the Brazil international is gradually showing more consistency and more measured performances. Like many of his teammates who were effectively ruled out as finished by the fanbase, Fred is improving and making huge strides, the culmination of which was a complete 90-minute masterclass on Saturday against one of the best teams in Europe. Fred is proving to be a trusted Ten Hag ally that can be called upon whenever needed and do a job perfectly. A player who does not kick up a fuss nor complains about game time yet can be relied on regularly is an invaluable asset for any manager. United’s successful years were built on the backs of such players. Ji-Sung Park and Darren Fletcher are typical examples that personified this role within the team. I’m not for one minute saying that Fred is on the same level as Park and Fletcher, but he’s steadily cementing his place in the team to suit the roles the two United greats played. That he’s a likeable guy and a positive presence in the dressing room cannot be doubted. His effort even when in poor form is also undeniable.
Fred’s contract expires at the end of the season, although the club has triggered the one-year extension on his deal. Unlike in the case of Rashford, Diogo Dalot and David de Gea, there have so far been no conclusive reports indicating that United have opened talks with him and his representatives over fresh terms to keep him beyond next season. There’s still a long way to go but at the moment, Fred is making a strong case for a longer United stay. He’s contributing in a big way and helping advance Ten Hag’s agenda. The overall final decision of course rests with the United boss but on the balance of things, he must be heavily leaning towards keeping Fred.
Derick Kinoti
Manchester United fans have long had a soft spot for Anthony Martial but the time to move him on might just be now. Admittedly, the team are a different monster whenever he’s in the side but that’s exactly the problem. ‘Whenever’.
For whatever reason, Martial is now undoubtedly an injury-prone player. I suspect it has to do with the muscle he put on to try to adapt to English football. Perhaps his ligaments and tendons haven’t caught up with him and are struggling to deal with the extra KGs. Either way, speculation aside, he is a difference maker but he’s not available enough to make him being a difference maker valuable enough. A settled XI is a winning one and the striker position is arguably the one position Erik ten Hag is changing the most, which isn’t ideal.
We’ve created numerous big chances, up there with the best teams in the league, but the lack of a consistently available striker has seen us fall short at times. It’s something we can’t carry on doing next season if the goal is to build and go for a title challenge.
Ideally you’d keep Martial as a backup option. But we all know he’s not keen on that role. And we do have to factor in his age, his contract length, and his wages.
In the past, we’ve held onto players for far too long before being able to recoup a respectable amount of money for them. Given our financial struggles at the minute, it makes sense to sell Martial in the summer to fund a purchase of a fit, out and out number nine.
His contract ends in 2024 though we have an option to trigger a further year and he’s 27 years old, in the peak of his career. The time to sell is now.
Ten Hag has shown an ability to manage injury prone players and increase their robustness so far but it hasn’t worked for Martial in the same way it has with the likes of Raphael Varane for example.
In the Dutchman’s system, he’s pretty flexible with what kind of striker he can work with, which is the main reason why we’re even in a top four spot in the first place. Of course he has an idea of his ideal striker and he does seem to be a fan of Martial but it’s a pairing that doesn’t seem to make much sense anymore.
We need reliability. If even after being handled with care, Martial has to be consistently substituted, then it’s incredibly disruptive. Match plans go out of the window and it’s damaging to the game momentum.
It’s painful to say but it’s difficult to see an alternative scenario unless the former AS Monaco man can somehow prove his fitness before the season is over.
Red Moon
Yes, there has been a lot of disappointment. A lot of frustration, excuses, sulking, pained expressions, a lot of time spent in the physio room. It’s easy to understand why fans would want to say “enough is enough” when it comes to Anthony Martial and move him on.
If United had any other manager I’d probably agree, but I would like to give Ten Hag at least one more season to get the best out of this mercurial talent, because let’s face it, on his day, at his best, there are few better in the world. And if anyone can find the key to unlocking that talent, it’s Erik. He’s done it with Rashford, with Wan-Bissaka, with Shaw, with Fred, why not Martial?
Martial has only just turned 27. He’s coming into the peak years with bags of experience behind him. He could have 7, 8 more years at the top level. What would United get for him now, if they sold him? £25 million maybe? His market value as per transfermarkt.com is only €15 million. Whatever, whoever we could replace him with at that price, I doubt would be an upgrade. And conversely, imagine if he did have a good season, his best season, when he stays fit, scores 25 goals or more, and creates as many. What would he be worth then? Five times that amount.
There’s an old stock market saying, “buy low, sell high”. If United sell Martial now (assuming there isn’t time for a transformation of form and fortune this season), they will be surely selling low, and being United, we know they’ll be buying high when they replace him.
But it’s not just about economics. Ten Hag believes in Martial and we believe in Ten Hag. He was playing out of his skin in pre-season and it genuinely only feels as if it’s the constant injuries that are getting in the way now. If we actually had some alternatives, he’d probably have been given more time to recover from one injury before being pressed into action again. Let’s face it, the schedule this season is just stupid, thanks Fifa.
If you’d asked me at the start of this season to choose one to keep between Martial and Rashford, I’d have said keep Martial. That makes me look stupid at this particular point in time – and maybe I am – but Rashford’s resurgence shows how quickly things can be turned around in football. And as long as Erik believes he can do the same for Martial, I’m behind him 100%.
Red Billy
FA Cup Final, 12th May 1990: Manchester United 3 Crystal Palace 3
Four seasons into his reign as United manager, and it was fair to say, the ride had been bumpy for Alex Ferguson. The Scot had joined the sleeping giants of Manchester in 1986, taking over from the relatively successful, yet unpredictable Ron Atkinson, who had lead the club to two FA Cup finals in 83’ and 85’, successfully winning both.
After enjoying domestic and European success north of the border with Aberdeen, Ferguson had embarked on a job that even he would be amazed at the magnitude of. Although he lead the Reds to the runners up spot in the first division in his second season, United had languished in mid table since, with 11th and 13th placed finishes seemingly becoming the norm. Without even a hint of success, Ferguson had moved on many of the side’s regular starters, replacing them with steady, consistent players and a good sprinkling of youngsters, as is the United way. And it was one of those youth team products who got the team off to a great start in the FA Cup, saving Fergie’s job in the process.
Mark Robins, a 20-year-old Lancashire lad, scored the only goal of a third round tie against Forest, propelling the team’s cup run as well as his manager’s glittering career at Old Trafford. Providing the winning extra-time goal in the semi-final replay against Oldham as well, ensured that Robins and Ferguson would have a shot at silverware. With 80,000 fans packed into Wembley, Ferguson was up against ex United favourite Steve Coppell, leading his Palace team to their first ever major cup final, a team who had finished two places below United, in what was to be a thriller.
As skipper Bryan Robson lined his side up, it was Palace that offered the early threat. And with a well worked free kick on United’s left, Gary O’Reilly met a floated cross which looped over the head of United’s keeper Jim Leighton, Steve Bruce unable to clear it off of the line, and first blood to the underdogs after 18 minutes played. Cue the Reds own Captain Marvel to the rescue, Robson heading home a near post header from some good work out wide by Brian McClair, taking the sides in at half-time all square.
United were playing well as the second half got underway, and it was Mark Hughes who put the Red Devils in control on 62 minutes with a left-foot half volley as the ball fell loose in the Palace box. The introduction of Ian Wright saw Palace fight back however, the striker turning Gary Pallister in the United box before easily sliding the ball home for 2-2 and extra-time. No sooner had the added 30 minutes begun, and Wright was at it again, meeting a deep cross that evaded the hapless Leighton and giving the Londoners a glimpse of the trophy.
But the Palace defenders tired, Ferguson threw on Robins in search of an equaliser and some good play by Paul Ince and Danny Wallace, coupled with the constant movement by Hughes that the defence just couldn’t cope with, saw United create chances. And that pressure paid off on the 113th minute as Sparky beat the offside trap and slid his shot past the oncoming Nigel Martin, before reeling away to the celebrating United faithful, punching the air in delight.
The final score 3-3, and what a match. United and Palace will meet each other again in the Premier League in just 2 weeks time, and they would have to meet them again at Wembley to conclude this thrilling cup tie.
United line-up: Jim Leighton, Paul Ince, Steve Bruce, Gary Pallister (Mark Robins), Lee Martin (Clayton Blackmore), Danny Wallace, Bryan Robson, Mike Phelan, Neil Webb, Brian McClair, Mark Hughes.
Paul Speller
When I was a young United fan coming to terms with the history of the club I would spend hours pestering my family about the great players of days gone by. I had an almost inexhaustible appetite for stories of the Busby Babes and would ask for minute detail about what made them great. Who was the most skilful? Best. Who had the hardest shot? Charlton. Who was the biggest handful for defenders? Law. Entire afternoons, evenings and weekends spent getting my dad and uncle to reanimate the magic of the past to distract from the barren present.
Now, as a fan of advancing years, I find myself on the other side of the conversation. Such is life. It’s a source of bittersweet pleasure to realise that we’re now further removed from the Reds’ marvellous 90s heyday as I was back then from the Busby era. Astonishingly, we’re quickly closing in on it being 30 years since the club finally emerged from 26 years in the relative wilderness to become champions of England again.
Central to that was a certain Frenchman with a puffed out chest, upturned collar and inimitable swagger.
The arrival of Eric Cantona changed everything. I still remember coming home from school to flick on Teletext and reading that Fergie had ‘swooped’ to land the mercurial enfant terrible who had inspired Leeds to the title – pipping United in harrowing circumstances – just a few months earlier. Was this a good thing? Why would Leeds sell such a talented player to us? Say what about Leslie Ash?
Cantona arrived at a club that was visibly suffering from an existential hangover following the previous campaign. Struggling for form and without injured striker Dion Dublin, the Reds sat in 8th place in the table with just 2 wins in 13 games. Inspired by the France international, they not only turned the season around but beat Aston Villa to the title, exorcising the seemingly neverending wait to become champions once again.
It’s difficult to overstate just how much of our long-awaited success was down to the Frenchman. From the moment he arrived it just felt like the perfect union of player and club. A man who had had a nomadic existence and brought with him a reputation for being problematic found the right club and manager to get the best out of him. In return, the club got a talisman blessed with a perfect touch, strength, vision, finishing ability and, perhaps most importantly, an aura. When Eric strutted out on the pitch the failures of the past dissolved. This man knew exactly what he was doing and became a Red icon almost overnight.
Cantona could do everything. He could unlock a defence with an impudent pass, control and volley a shot from 25 yards or bring down a pass and unleash a fierce drive in one silky, fluid motion. He was at the centre of everything good – probing, moving, scoring, inspiring. Some days you could watch him for 90 minutes and not witness a single misstep. In a star-studded line up containing the likes of Giggs, Kanchelskis, Hughes and Ince, Eric was the creative spark and lethal finisher. He stood alone, in Fergie’s words “…made for Manchester United.”
In a broader context, his arrival sparked a period of domestic dominance not seen since the 60s. With Cantona in the side, United won 4 titles in 5 years and 2 FA Cups. The one title they didn’t win – losing out to Blackburn in ’95 – just happened to be the season he was banned for months because of his Selhurst Park Kung Fu kick. The season he returned was arguably his pinnacle, with him scoring vital goals on a weekly basis to steer a young side to another double. He even scored the winner in the Cup Final against none other than Liverpool.
There’s a compelling argument to be made that everything that followed – the treble, the sustained domestic dominance, the club’s preeminence at the forefront of the Premier League becoming the most watched global competition – all came from Eric’s arrival. All came from Leeds enquiring about Denis Irwin’s availability and ending up selling us their star striker instead.
Eric Cantona then. Old Trafford might have seen better finishers, better dribblers and better passers. But nobody who watched him play could fail to leave him out of their all-time favourite side. He was magical. He was, quite simply, the King.
Scott Eckersley
Some of the best United-related videos on Youtube since the last match
The January transfer window is open for the women’s game as it is the men’s. There have been a number of big signings in the WSL already as Tottenham bought Beth England from Chelsea and Jordan Nobbs made her new home at Aston Villa. Manchester United have bid farewell to Lucy Staniforth, who also joins Aston Villa permanently, and Grace Clinton, who has joined Bristol City. But United are yet to bring any new players in. However, they have been linked to a number of exciting names.
The first and most consistent rumour has been that the Reds are on the verge of signing Canadian international Jayde Riviere. The 21 year old defender is a free agent and has been linked with a move to the WSL with BBC’s Emma Sanders confirming those reports. Riviere was a part of the Canadian team who won the Gold medal at the postponed 2020 Olympics in Tokyo. She had surgery back in September and has recently returned to training. Riviere is a product of the US college system that has previously helped to nurture such talented players as Alessia Russo. United have struggled defensively in the second half of the season in previous years, so it would be no surprise if this was a key area that Skinner would like to strengthen. According to journalist Jamie Spencer of 90 Min, The Reds have also been linked with 19 year old Hanna Wijk from BK Hacken, who already has Champions League experience.
With the exit of Staniforth in this window and having not replaced Jackie Groenen after she exited last summer, Skinner is also on the hunt for a midfielder. In the last couple of weeks the Reds have been heavily linked with Norwegian international Lisa Naalsund. United were reportedly close to signing a deal with the 27 year old but their hopes suffered a blow when she told Norwegian press that the thing that was holding up the transfer was the doubts surrounding game time. “There is quite tough competition in that club, so if you get there you risk sitting on the bench for 6 months. Then you won’t be match-ready for the World Cup,” she said.
In the meantime, United showed an interest in Estelle Cascarino, who currently plays as a defender for PSG. It was first reported last week that United are watching the French international closely and according to Culture PSG they are looking into signing her as a midfielder, the position which she first started out in. Cascarino has made 17 appearances for PSG since her arrival in 2021 and is under contract until 2024. She has a twin sister, Delphine, who plays for Lyon and the French national team alongside her.
They are three promising players but United are not the only ones linked with them so will have to move quickly. The talk on the terrace at the Reds’ game against Liverpool was that Cascarino has already signed for the club whilst Riviere is edging closer. Naalsund’s comments to her national press could have jeopardised a deal further but there are still a couple of weeks left for both sides to come to an agreement.
Zoe Hodges
Some of the best United-related posts on Twitter since the last match
Clicking on a video tweet will open it in Twitter in a new window.
mystery Manc
Who is this disguised as Fred the Red? Click the button to reveal the right answer.
Drag the pieces below to solve this United jigsaw. The default jigsaw has 48 pieces but you can change this by clicking the ‘Play On Jigsawplanet’ button and selecting a different size (opens in new window, no sign in necessary).
Crossword
What a performance against City. 100% 100% ground duels won, 3/4 successful tackles, 100% successful dribbles, 1 intercept, 5 recoveries and a chain skill move like something out of the FIFA (console game) World Cup.
We just wanted to gloat. 10 points behind us now having played a game more. United’s cunning plan to trick him into buying Nunez and Gakpo was genius.
| Cookie | Duration | Description |
|---|---|---|
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". |
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional | 11 months | The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". |
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". |
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-others | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. |
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". |
| viewed_cookie_policy | 11 months | The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data. |
To read the magazine, simply scroll down, or click the down arrow at the top of any page to bring up the table of contents:
This issue will be updated every morning until match day and after the manager’s press conference. You can see the date it was last updated on the magazine’s footer.
Click here to close the magazine and return to United Matchday Magazine home page.
Answer: Marouane Fellaini. Well done if you got it right!
1. Robson
2. Rimmer
3. Rashford
4. Rossi
5. Rooney
6. Ritchie
7. Rojo
8. Rafael
9. Rowley
10. Romero
11. Rangnick
12. Robins