editorial

Are the underdogs about to become überdogs?

If United win on June 3rd and Inter Milan win on June 10th, Manchester United will have won more trophies than Manchester City this season. And stranger things have certainly happened. Of course, that won’t mean that United are better than City, but it will prove a point – that winners and losers are defined by small margins.

In our lead article today, Darragh Fox discusses how United can use their underdog status to upset the sky blue applecart and he suggests some tactical tweaks from Ten Hag that could outwit Guardiola for a second time this season. David O’Neill’s own excellent tactical analysis of the game provides an in-depth look at some of the on-pitch battles that will need to be won by Erik ten Hag’s men.

Why is it so important? It’s history of course. And as Ayantan Chowdhury points out, one of the very things that defines Manchester United – the unique treble – is on the line. And let’s face it, nobody fancies that bunch of United rejects, Lukaku, Mkhitaryan, Darmian et al, to put a stop to them. So it’s on United to preserve their own legacy, at Wembley, in the FA Cup final.

Two key players in the United side trying to achieve just that are Casemiro and David de Gea. Both have had their issues this season. The Brazilian’s disciplinary record is examined by Derick Kinoti in this issue, while Red Billy is concerned that the wrong kind of history is repeating itself with De Gea.

As for how long it will take United to be able to come into an encounter like this on an even footing, our Devils’ Advocate debaters have good arguments both ways for whether it will be more or less than two years. A lot will depend of course on what happens next at the club level.

At the time of writing, the new owner of the club remains unknown. In his column, Eckers suggests that another part of what forges United’s identity – and what sets them apart from City whether they win or lose on June 3rd – is that they have to work for what they have, it is not handed them on a plate by some sportswashing project. Meanwhile, Billy pops up again to point out that despite those gazillions, City’s net spend over the last five years has been half that of United’s. It’s clearly not just about throwing money at the problem and thinking we’ll all be happy three years or less down the line.

As for that takeover, if and when it happens we’ll be here with a special evolving edition of the matchday mag. It will be published on the day of the announcement and will continue to grow as the news and views of all those concerned comes to light. And we’ll be celebrating getting the Glazers out, finally, after years of trying. Keep your eye out for that one, which will mark another historic milestone in the history of our club. And if it’s already happened by the time you’re reading this, high five, they’re gone!

Latest united news

powered by

Peoples_Person_simple-logo1-white-bg-on-text

Embracing the Role of Underdog

Ten Hag would prefer to be proactive against City, but he knows the situation calls for compromise

Rocky Balboa lacing up his gloves as the mean and merciless Ivan Drogo awaits. David carefully searching for the right stone as Goliath menacingly watches on. Erik Ten Hag and a white board with eleven red pins planning to overcome a Blue Wave. Manchester United have certainly been cast in the stereotypical role of underdog as the FA Cup final against their bitter neighbours fast approaches, and their fans will be praying for a Hollywood ending of biblical proportions.

Manchester City have played thirty four games since football returned from the World Cup, winning twenty-six matches, drawing five and losing on just three occasions. It represents a run of form nothing short of imperious, with Real Madrid the latest club to fall victim to their unrelenting quality. Guardiola’s men made Ancelotti’s team look like boys at the Etihad as the Citizens progressed to the Champions League final with aplomb. A spirited, but ultimately substandard, Inter Milan team awaits. Another victim to inevitably add to the list and the prospect of the long-awaited European validation Guardiola has coveted since arriving in Manchester.

Domestically, Arsenal’s late season implosion has ensured City may not even need to win another match to claim a third successive Premier League title. They have not lost a league game in over one hundred days; an almost impossible standard to match. In a season as long and draining as this World Cup-impacted one, a squad with the expensively assembled depth of City’s has naturally outlasted its competitors. The validity of the means by which this selection of players was acquired is undeniably questionable; the quality of them is not. The pieces are slowly, but surely, falling into place for a potential treble. With Erik Ten Hag and his whiteboard the only meaningful obstacle left to overcome.

The 1998/99 season constitutes the competitive apex of Sir Alex Ferguson’s Old Trafford career. No other English side in history has been able to win the esteemed ‘Treble’, despite many false dawns. If Manchester City were able to achieve such an accolade it could prove decisive in legitimising the long-term sportswashing project that has come to dominate English football, particularly to younger fans. Billions of pounds have been invested into Manchester City (and Manchester in general) since the Abu Dhabi United Group acquired in the club in 2008, with a clear and coherent plan for exactly how the eye-watering sums should be spent. Imagine Goliath, but pumped full of expensive steroids and wearing the finest armour known to man. Good luck David.

The key to overcoming such a challenge for Manchester United is to readily accept the reality of the situation. United are the underdogs, embrace it. The notion of going toe-to-toe with this Manchester City team, in the dominant form they find themselves, borders on fantasy.

In the past month and half, Arsenal, Liverpool and Real Madrid have all attempted to engage with City from a position of footballing parity. Arteta, Klopp and Ancelotti refused to curtail their gameplans from the usual positions of strength they find themselves in. They attempted to meet Goliath in the middle of the battlefield and exchange blows directly. The results? A 4-1 loss for each of the English teams and a 4-0 loss for the Spanish. The games were hardly competitive affairs, more like expensive and grandiose training sessions. There was little for Ten Hag and his whiteboard to learn from here.

Rather, he must look towards the matches in which the unrelenting Blue Wave has displayed moments of weakness. Since the World Cup, City have lost three games – once to United themselves, once to Tottenham in the league, and once to Southampton in the Carabao Cup. In all three games, the respective managers standing across the dugout from Guardiola recognised the quality they were encountering and made necessary adjustments.

United and Southampton adopted similar set ups; choosing to buttress the midfield with an additional player, while moving their normal central midfielder (Christian Eriksen and James Ward-Prowse respectively) into the number ten role. The extra legs in midfield enabled the teams to track the sea of options Manchester City attack with more effectively. Spurs’ tactic deviated slightly, with their usual formation, a 3-4-3 system, instead relying on the forwards to drop into midfield when out of possession. The effect was the same however – congestion of the centre of the pitch paired with quick and decisive transitions.

It is not necessarily the style of football which Ten Hag would classify as his ideal. Speaking to Robin van Persie in a recent interview with BT Sport, the Dutch manager detailed how he has a ‘certain philosophy about how I want to see football…one thing is I want to play attacking, I want to play proactive.’ He went on to explain, however, the nature of management is adjusting between your ideal and the reality of your group of players.

‘It’s not about the way you want to play, but the players – they decide and they dictate the philosophy of how you play. You have to adapt, definitely.’

This adaptation process is paramount for overcoming City. While Ten Hag evidently values the technical ability of Diogo Dalot in the right-back position, this is the game for The Spider. Despite Ten Hag’s obvious preference for the Eriksen and Casemiro double pivot behind Bruno Fernandes due to that midfield’s quality on the ball, this is the game for Fred. Even though the Dutch manager has repeatedly stressed his admiration for Anthony Martial in the centre-forward position, valuing his hold up play and focal point abilities, this is the game for Marcus Rashford through the middle.

Wan-Bissaka has the ability to completely lockdown an opposition winger. In the current form of Jack Grealish, with his direct and powerful style of dribbling, Wan-Bissaka is a much more suitable countermeasure than Dalot. The calming and instructive presence of Raphaël Varane will be vital next to him, with the French defender thankfully returning from injury recently.

The definition of inconsistency should be removed from the dictionary and, in its place, a picture of Frederico Rodrigues de Paula Santos should be inserted instead. Fred drifts between an impression of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde on a game-to-game basis, ranging from great to ghastly with seemingly zero indication of which version you will see.

The Fred who played against City earlier in the year, however, was fantastic. He man-marked Kevin De Bruyne out of the game off the ball while enabling fast counter-attacks on it. It was a quintessential underdog performance and a requisite for success on June 3rd.

Further forward, Martial certainly fits the mould of what Ten Hag looks for in his ideal striker. Speaking earlier in the season, the Dutchman said:

‘…in my way of playing I like the type [of player] Antony Martial is, because he can hold the ball. He is a [also] a target, he can link up, but he can also run behind. He has speed, he can finish, and he has good pressure [presses well].’

Yet it is the pace and directness of Marcus Rashford which will give Guardiola restless nights. Manchester City’s antidote to speed is Kyle Walker. The defender, even in the unconventional system City have recently been playing, operates on the right-hand side of defence. He absolutely shutdown Vinícius Júnior in the Champions League match, with the worry being he may do the same to Rashford if Marcus lines up in his usual left-wing role. With the freedom to play through the middle, and position himself on the shoulder of City’s slower defenders, the threat of a viable counter attack increases. It also permits for a more defensively sound player (Bruno Fernandes for example) to operate on the left-hand side – someone who will track back much more diligently than Rashford.

Every conceivable effort must be made to make life uncomfortable for Manchester City. They can be given no time on the ball in advanced positions. Their penchant for creating overloads must be curtailed. The freedom with which their defenders operate cannot be allowed. The space they leave between defence and goalkeeper must be exploited.

While Ten Hag would certainly dream of a scenario in which these facets of City’s game could be countered by proactive football, this Manchester United squad are not currently there. They are in the infancy of their evolution; a transition from reactive to proactive football. But in a contest such as this, with the odds stacked firmly against them, United will have to revert to their reactive foundation, actively encouraged by a manager to betraying his ideals who embraces the role of the plucky underdog. David must recognise the (illegal) might of Goliath, and plan accordingly.

Darragh Fox

Meet the opposition: Manchester city

The all-conquering City juggernaut could be on the cusp of winning The Treble come June 3

Manager: pep guardiola

This might just be the year Guardiola completes English football. From being second for most of the Premier League season, they have managed to outgun Arsenal in the final stretch and are looking at a three-peat. They are favourites to win the Champions League with only Inter Milan standing in their way. The FA Cup provides the chance to emulate Sir Alex Ferguson and his famous Treble-winning feat! He has completely revolutionised City's playing style and trophies just keep on coming.

Top scorer: erling haaland

Most fans and pundits were sure that Haaland would be a success in the Premier League. But nobody could have envisaged the kind of impact he has had in his debut season -- 52 goals and eight assists in 48 appearances is ludicrous! He has already claimed the record for most goals in a single Premier League season, while he has also broken the record for most goals in one season in all competitions by a Premier League player. The Golden Boot and a Treble could be lying in wait for the machine at the end of the season.

club and fans

City have recently launched a legal challenge against the Premier League’s 115 charges in relation to alleged financial malpractice. They were accused in February of breaking a host of rules around income and expenditure. Punishment if found guilty includes being banned from the competition and even having their titles expunged. City's biggest issue with the whole thing is regarding the presence of Murray Rosen KC, who is supposedly an Arsenal member. This latest challenge from City could mean the issue is likely to take even longer to be resolved, possibly as long as four years.

player to watch: kevin de bruyne

The Belgian has been one of the best players to wear the City shirt and his ability to unlock stubborn defences remains unmatched. Assists and goals have flowed freely since his move to Manchester, and now with Haaland by his side, the duo have created hell for the opposition time and time again. The 31-year-old has scored 64 goals and made 101 assists in 237 Premier League games for City and he also has the chance to break Arsenal legend Thierry Henry's record of most assists (20) in a Premier League season. The City star is two shy of that elusive number. Add to it the chance to claim the Treble and De Bruyne could certainly claim the mantle of City's greatest ever player at the end of the current season.

interesting stats

For the first time, a Manchester derby will be played in the FA Cup final. Across all competitions, since 1881, the two sides have met a total of 189 times, with 78 wins for United, 58 for City, and 53 draws. FA Cup clashes between the two teams have been few and far between over the years with the first one coming in the 1891 FA Cup, when City were still known as Ardwick AFC, with United winning 5-1. City got their revenge in 1925/26 competition, winning 3-0 at the semifinal stage, before going on to lose to Bolton Wanderers in the final. City continued their impressive FA Cup derby record with a win over United in 1955, before suffering their first loss in the 1970 competition. United won the following three ties, as their paths began to separate in the 1990's and early 2000's, with the two post-2008 clashes serving memorable ties, with one win each.

FORM AND INJURIES

City have been in irresistible form during the season run-in. Pep Guardiola's side have won their last 11 consecutive league games, scoring a league-high 17 goals across the previous six matches and conceding just four. That's not all as City are unbeaten in 23 games in all competitions (W19 D4). They could wrap up the Premier League title at the weekend against Chelsea before the Wembley date with United on Saturday 3 June, with the trip to Istanbul the last potential hurdle to clear against Inter Milan. They missed Nathan Ake during the second-leg against Real Madrid but he is expected to be back in time for the Wembley game.

match preview

All the latest information about the upcoming game.

Team News and Predicted XI

As said elsewhere in this magazine, going up against City with an attacking line-up is asking for trouble. Ten Hag tweaked his formation in the 2-1 victory at Old Trafford, bringing in Fred for extra energy in midfield and that was successful. We think that Ten Hag will do that again.

However, in January Anthony Martial led the line, with Marcus Rashford on the left and Bruno Fernandes on the right. We think this time the manager might prefer the mercurial Antony over Martial, unless the Frenchman hits better form between the time of writing and June 3rd.

This could mean Rashford playing up front and the undroppable Bruno Fernandes playing out left, but Ten Hag could opt to play Bruno as a false 9, with Rashford retaining the left wing role. The pair could interchange, with Rashford cutting into the box, Bruno dropping back and Luke Shaw providing the width from the left side.

This would allow United to crowd the midfield with Casemiro sitting and with Fred and Christian Eriksen ahead of him.

In defence, Aaron Wan-Bissaka will probably get the nod over Diogo Dalot. Whether it’s Mahrez or Grealish, Wan-Bissaka is probably better adapted to the one-on-one situations that will need to be dealt with.

Raphael Varane and Victor Lindelof should be the automatic choice at centre back in the absence of Lisandro Martinez. David de Gea is certainly the automatic choice in goal.

We would expect the likes of Alejandro Garnacho and Scott McTominay to get minutes off the bench, depending on whether the task is to attack or hold on to what we’ve got. The manager also likes to give Harry Maguire 10-15 minutes to shore up the defence in tight situations.

Links

Match officials

Referee: Paul Tierney

Assistants: Neil Davies, Scott Ledger

Fourth official: Peter Bankes

VAR: David Coote
Assistant VAR: Simon Long

tactical preview

Erik ten Hag and Pep Guardiola have faced off in Manchester derbies twice now, with the first encounter ending in a 6-3 defeat at the Etihad. Ahead of the reverse fixture, Ten Hag promised that his United side had come a long way since that disheartening result and backed that up by securing a 2-1 win at Old Trafford. It is apparent, ahead of the FA Cup final, that both teams are different beasts again since the league meeting, and how those differences play out at Wembley will go a long way to determining who lifts England’s most prestigious knockout trophy.

Many of United’s developments since January 14th have been born of necessity, with injuries taking their toll amidst a hectic schedule. In City’s case, it seems that Guardiola has settled on a winning formula, having spent much of the season tinkering with his star-studded squad.

His use of John Stones as a false fullback has been the talk of many pundits as an innovation. In truth, it is not at all that strange a concept, and merely an elegant solution to the teething problems City had in integrating Erling Haaland into their side. In Guardiola’s system, achieving numerical superiority in midfield is paramount and – without the option of a false nine given the Norwegian’s scoring prowess – the extra man had to come from somewhere.

It is because of this that City have adopted a 3-2-4-1 possession structure in recent weeks. The system is basically the old ‘WM’ formation from before the 1960s, but its merits in modern football are clear. The ‘3-2’ base provides solidity against counterattacks (doubly so when using athletic central defenders as City have done), while the ‘4-1’ element have plenty of freedom to attack.

But the true strength of the system lies in the box midfield that links defence and attack. For Man City, Rodri and Stones form a double pivot with Gundogan and Kevin de Bruyne ahead of them as attacking midfielders. The result is a quartet able to circulate possession at ease – they are essentially playing a rondo in the middle of the pitch half the time. It allows them to move the ball from side to side, or vertically, at speed.

Erik ten Hag has typically opted to use a man-orientated press in midfield when playing against sides comfortable on the ball. Doing so against the box midfield will take some alterations, and it will likely affect his team selection in the final. It would be no surprise to see Bruno Fernandes start on the left in this match. While the Portugal star is clearly a natural in the number ten role, his work rate and pressing could be a decisive factor in congesting that ‘Stones channel’ City like to use in their build-up. And just as Guardiola will want to gain an extra man in midfield, so too will Ten Hag.

But the most productive way of disrupting their build-up play could come earlier in its sequence, before the 3-2-4-1 has taken shape. City are determined to play through the middle at every available opportunity, primarily because players have fewer passing options when walled off by the touchline. Forcing City into those areas early on in their build-up could be a decent way to blunt their possession.

It is likely that Ten Hag will have his centre forward press from the very middle of the box, angling his run so as to deny access between the central defenders. With Rodri marked, the only viable passing option for the City defender would be out towards the touchline. Here it is ‘safe’ to press hard and as a unit – there is nowhere to go for the fullback besides down the line to a marked man, who will likely be unable to do much on his own. Of course, this will not yield rewards every time and good players often find solutions, but it could prove a fruitful avenue to defusing City’s attempt to set up shop in the United half, and perhaps even create goalscoring chances from high turnovers.

But what many United fans will be most worried about is how to avoid Man City’s own press. Doubtless, this is a valid concern given the Red Devils’ difficulties in playing out from the back. David de Gea has made a number of high profile errors in this regard and the absence of Lisandro Martinez has been keenly felt since the loss against Sevilla.

And the Sky Blues are among the best around at forcing errors high up the pitch. While they usually start in a 4-3-3 and build in a 3-2-4-1, City typically press in a 4-2-4 shape, with De Bruyne moving up alongside Haaland. The intention is to smother their opponents’ defence, and it often works. Since United lack central defenders comfortable in working their way out of such situations, playing short would be ill-advised. A drilled pass into the midfield area, where United would enjoy a temporary numerical superiority, would be ideal, but with De Gea, that simply is not going to happen.

The safest choice, therefore, is for the Spaniard to target the space afforded by City’s wingers moving up to engage United’s fullbacks. This is actually the sort of pass De Gea is relatively comfortable with and could provide his wingers with valuable time on the ball. Should they move it fast enough, United may even be able to take advantage of their numbers in the midfield zone to quickly work an opportunity for a direct ball in behind City’s high backline, creating an artificial transition.

In this way United can potentially turn one of the weakest areas of their game into a strength, as it is difficult to imagine Guardiola not wanting to take advantage of De Gea’s poor distribution by keeping with his aggressive front-four press. If the keeper can find the wings, United have the pace to make use of that space, along with quality passers in midfield to potentially switch play at speed.

Both Erik ten Hag and Pep Guardiola are masters at making adjustments to their build-up and pressing structures on the fly, so we will likely see both managers lively on the touchline during the match. The smallest detail could prove the difference between winning and losing in a tense derby final – expect a game of tweaks.

David O’Neill

 

transfer rumours

What’s hot, what’s real and what’s not

In this section we look at some of the most active transfer stories of the week about United, both comings and goings. We give each story a fire rating (how hot the story is, out of five) and a star rating (how reliable the story is, out of five).

our top transfer tip

🔥

Rated 4 out of 5
Jeremie Frimpong (Bayer Leverkusen)

This one fits like a glove. Dutch star, so will be well-known to Ten Hag, 22 years old, incredible season behind him, good price point (€35m) and in a position we know Ten Hag is desperate to strengthen.

With the departure of either Dalot or Wan-Bissaka likely to raise a good chunk of the funds needed to buy Frimpong, this is our hot tip for a summer transfer.

🔥🔥🔥🔥

Rated 4 out of 5
victor osimhen (napoli)

The press still seem divided over whether it is Harry Kane or Napoli’s crown jewel that is top of United’s wishlist.

Osimhen’s price was rising to around €160m, then president De Laurentiis said he is not for sale this summer, then reports came out that Napoli would have to look at offers around €120m plus €10m for the striker.

Osimhen wants to play in the Premier League but is also in no hurry to leave Napoli, where he’s enjoying life. PSG are also now sniffing around, so there’s going to be a lot of tough negotiating.

🔥🔥🔥🔥

Rated 4 out of 5
Harry Kane (Spurs)

Thomas Tuchel is reportedly keen on taking Kane to Bayern and those rumours have been persisting for some weeks. PSG are also in for him as well.

Kane is reportedly keen on staying in the Premier League as he closes in on Alan Shearer’s all-time goalscoring record (260 vs 210). However, Spurs chief Daniel Levy would prefer to not sell him to a competitor, so this, too, is complicated.

🔥🔥🔥

Rated 1 out of 5
Randal kolo muani (Eintracht Frankfurt)

Christian Falk, a leading German transfer specialist, insists United are very serious about Kolo Muani and have a €120m bid prepared. This story has repeated over the course of weeks.

As we said previously, it seems highly unlikely that United would sanction that amount at this stage, especially when the likes of Kane and Osimhen are around for about the same. Meanwhile, recent reports claim that Randal is planning to snub United’s advances anyway because he wants a Bayern Munich move.

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Rated 2.5 out of 5
Kim Min-jae (Napoli)

Kim has a €60m release clause that is only active for a few weeks in July, but multiple reports claim United could pounce. Reports have been raging that the deal is very close and has been agreed by all parties, but his own agent spoke out this week and said that things weren’t so advanced and that there had been no contact from United. We think this is probably true as Ten Hag’s priority this summer must be a striker and a midfielder, with Victor Lindelof having done enough lately to prove himself a capable backup for Varane and Martinez alongside Luke Shaw.

 

🔥🔥

Rated 2 out of 5
Diogo Costa (FC Porto)

David de Gea’s new contract is reportedly all but signed, but rumours of interest in other keepers continue to come thick and fast, with Costa still top of the list.

United scouts seem to be in attendance at virtually every Porto game, but will they have €70m to trigger his release clause? Or will Porto negotiate?

Photo gallery

FA Cup victories over the years

All photos from Getty Images

the final frontier

Ten Hag has the unenviable task of preserving the legacy of Manchester United’s greatest achievement

Rewind back to the 26th of March in the year 1999 and suddenly you hear Clive Tyldesley shout “And Solskjaer has won it!” and it is goosebumps all over again. Those words are etched into the minds of every Manchester United fan around the globe, be it young or old. It was The Treble, a feat not achieved by any English club and it was the pinnacle of success and United stood at the top, alone with envious glances arriving from all over. That glorious achievement has stood the test of time and for 24 years United fans have kept signing from the rafters about being the only one to ever do the unthinkable. That is until now…

It has been a strange time to be a United fan since the great Sir Alex Ferguson retired 10 years ago. United’s arch rivals have gained in strength and have competed for the biggest prizes while United have sat back and allowed them a free run. United were powerless to stop Liverpool from winning their 19th league title that took them to within one title of the Reds while Arsenal are showing signs of getting back to their best. Noisy neighbours Manchester City have kept adding prizes at a rate of knots and now they are standing on the cusp of emulating our greatest feat.

The Manchester Derby on June 3 will be the first time that both teams will come face-to-face in the summit clash of the FA Cup and the current form City are displaying is scary. Pep Guardiola has been hinting at how fired up his squad of players are at the prospect of being immortalised alongside the red half of Manchester. The Spanish coach also mocked United fans in the last FA Cup post-match press conference and said, “They don’t have to be scared, we are neighbours, neighbours are always nice to each other.” By the time Wembley comes calling, City are expected to have wrapped up the Premier League title and that will give them huge confidence. The way they decimated European royalty in the form of Real Madrid in the Champions League semi-final was unheard of and was a timely warning to all that they really do mean business this season. The only thing that will stand in their way is Erik ten Hag and his inconsistent United side.

The Dutch manager has done a fabulous job so far especially considering the hand that he was dealt with. From massive injury concerns, to a lack of squad depth coupled with a fallout with his biggest superstar, Ten Hag has had to overcome challenges of varying degrees but he has held firm and has maintained that whenever the Red Devils step onto the pitch, it is to win. Not many would have envisaged a Carabao Cup triumph, a top-four finish in the league and an FA Cup final appearance after the Brentford disaster back in August of last year. And now trophies aside, the Dutchman and his team must stop the unthinkable from happening. They have already shown they can stop Erling Haaland & Co once, why not at Wembley with their legacy on the line?

The current team is far from the finished article and with injuries to key personnel and loss of form affecting their top goalscorer, things are not looking too good for the 20-time English league champions. Lisandro Martinez will be a huge miss with United not only needing the World Cup winner’s aggressiveness but his innate ability to turn on a six-pence and spare David de Gea’s blushes while playing out from the back. There are also concerns over top-scorer Marcus Rashford’s form heading into the season finale. After a blistering spell post the World Cup where he bagged 16 goals in his first 17 appearances post Qatar, the Mancunian has managed a lowly five strikes in his last 17 games across all competitions. The only thing going for the Red Devils — under Ten Hag they have shown resilience and fighting spirit on numerous occasions and come June 3rd, they will need to do what is required one last time.

It is destiny then that Erik ten Hag now has the chance to stop City in their tracks and preserve his club’s legacy. The fans love him and he could become a cult hero if he manages to stop the unthinkable from happening. United have been a decent Cup side this term with their biggest performances coming in knockout competitions and it will suit United in a one-off game as they are simply not good enough to withstand a City onslaught in the league or in a two-legged tie. Former United legend Gary Neville had said on the Overlap Fan debate that he thought City’s biggest challenge for the FA Cup final will be history and it actually makes sense. United have their history to protect and get inspiration from and Ten Hag also hinted at going all out to ensure he preserves that legacy.

“We will do everything to give them that. We will give everything. More than 100 per cent you can’t do. The fans can rely on that,” the Dutch boss exclaimed at the end of the Brighton humdinger.

The Old Trafford faithful still sing the iconic song as a reminder to their opponents: “Have you ever won a treble?” It could change in June or Ten Hag and his band of merry men could be the basis for a whole new song. It looks like an uphill struggle but as the scorer of that famous goal said a couple of years back — “Mountains are there to be climbed“. And United will be roared on by millions around the world as they attempt to protect their final frontier from being overrun. All we can do now is Hope!

Ayantan Chowdhury

The devil's advocate

“United are at least two years away from catching up with City””
The case for ...

United are at least 2 years away from catching up with City

Ralf Rangnick once said Manchester United are about ten players away from challenging for the title. Not only did we not quite sign that many players since he said it (not permanently anyways) but he didn’t necessarily mean we’d immediately win the title either.

It was ten players just to challenge, let alone win. And it all depended on United signing the right profiles for all ten players, while simultaneously getting rid of the right players too. Rangnick described it as easy or not rocket science. It certainly feels that way for United’s recruitment department. Plus, what his statement perhaps didn’t factor in was City’s squad – they’re experienced, serial Premier League winners now. United lack that now. Only David de Gea will (potentially) remain next season from Sir Alex Ferguson’s last title win.

The only way United catch up to City in two year’s time is if City make mistake after mistake in the transfer market and lose Pep Guardiola at the same time. We’re also being incredibly optimistic of United actually having the funds or the brains to sign the right profiles needed.

United always seem to face the infamous Hydra dragon whenever it comes to squad building too. When one position is plugged, suddenly two more sprout out that need addressing. It seems endless.

Take Casemiro for example. A superb signing who’s finally proved fans right that a true defensive-midfielder has been missing ever since Michael Carrick retired. Unfortunately, the Brazilian doesn’t have a true back up in his position, nor will he be in the peak of his career for much longer. Casemiro already showed signs of struggling to keep up with the intensity of the league when playing week in, week out, and clearly needed time to rest between matches.

Anyway, back to the point, righting the wrongs of the past decade will take more than just two years. Although we’re heading in the right direction with Erik ten Hag, chances are we’ll be a cup team for a few seasons before we eventually can go toe to toe with City regularly.

And catching up to City doesn’t mean just winning one title then disappearing again (hello Liverpool). The title has to be going back and forth between ourselves and City (or preferably just staying at Old Trafford permanently). But we all know how difficult that is. Building a legacy and a cycle of a team takes time, let alone trying to challenge City in the meantime.

The problem isn’t just recruiting players, the problem is, as we’ve seen this season, many of the players just aren’t suited to playing Ten Hag’s style. So it’s as though he’s building a team from scratch rather than adding a few players and calling it quits. Even if the new owners (if that even ever happens) have a blank cheque, it will still take time for signings to adapt, for a culture to set in, and for Ten Hag to get his ideas across.

Even if all these circumstances somehow magically become perfect, fans are looking at catching up with City (as in dominating the league) in three seasons’ time. Minimum. And that’s just being realistic.

Red Moon

The case against...

This time last year, Manchester United, still reeling from a 4-0 humbling at the Amex Stadium, succumbed to a 1-0 defeat to Crystal Palace. There was no realistic chance of catching fourth place at that point, but those two results had even a Europa League position in jeopardy, with West Ham chasing sixth place. 58 points and a goal difference of zero made for poor reading for United fans, most of whom were really just waiting for a gut-wrenching season to finally end.

 Fast-forward to now and United are looking good for a Champions League spot, are likely to finish on or above 70 points, and the atmosphere has done a complete about-face. The rate of improvement has been nothing short of phenomenal.

 Under Erik ten Hag, United have already become the most effective pressing teams in the league, creating more chances within ten seconds of a high turnover than any other team in the division. The team maintains its ability to hit opponents on the break, and have even created more big chances than Arsenal – league leaders for the vast majority of the campaign – this term. The ingredients are coming together.

 And the best thing about it all is that it is plain to see what other spices are needed to complete the manager’s recipe for success. Ten Hag has taken the club on leaps and bounds despite having no functional striker for the entire campaign. Anthony Martial has had woeful luck with injuries, resulting in Wout Weghorst – a fine professional, but far from the required standard – leading the line from the start in twenty matches. Add to that a number of issues with squad depth in the face of an endless stream of injury crises and it is plain to see just how good a job the manager has done in the face of adversity.

 It does not take two years to sign a striker, and United are reportedly already making moves to shore up their midfield and backline ahead of what promises to be a busy summer window. With the Glazers edging their way towards the exit door, it is easy to feel that things are moving slowly just now, but their departure is sure to see an explosion of activity in the transfer market that frees Ten Hag to accelerate his rebuild. Given how well he has integrated his new signings into the side thus far, it will be a short step from there to success.

 The Manchester City behemoth is a fearsome opponent, but while Arsenal may have ultimately fallen short, The Gunners have shown that gods can bleed. Mikel Arteta’s side had no right to challenge Pep Guardiola this season, but they did it anyway using a combination of tactical acumen, well thought out squad planning, and luck. Manchester United are good for the first, halfway through the second, and due for the third.

David O’Neill

newton heath

Classic United matches from yesteryear

FA Cup final, 21st/26th May 1983: Manchester United  2-2 Brighton and Hove Albion (replay 4-0)

Despite one of the biggest trophy-barren periods of the club’s history, confounded by not having won the league title since 1967, Manchester United entered the FA Cup Final having won it for the fourth time in their history as recently as six years before.

Fast forward 40 years and The Reds are back at Wembley, ready to go toe-to-toe with their city rivals, having beaten Brighton in the semi final, in what was to be a roller coaster of a final against the Seagulls in 1983.

Manager Ron Atkinson, despite being somewhat of a flamboyant and unpredictable character, had United playing some of the slickest football seen for years, and looking like serious contenders for silverware once more. With some exciting new players, the Old Trafford faithful travelling south to London had high expectations. Brighton, promoted to the first division for the first time in their history just four seasons before, were the shock cup finalists having finished rock-bottom in the league and thus being relegated. United however were buoyed by back-to-back third place finishes and the prospect of European football once more.

As the teams took to the already threadbare Wembley pitch, just shy of 100,000 fans had sold out the famous old stadium, and with United considered to be huge favourites over their first time finalist opponents, they had the early chances to take the lead. With the established England duo of Bryan Robson and Ray Wilkins running the midfield and the Irish combination of Frank Stapleton and Norman Whiteside up top, United were a force to be reckoned with, but it was Brighton who took control of the game which resulted in them earning a surprise early lead, with Scottish centre forward Gordon Smith heading a floated cross past United keeper Gary Bailey in just the 14th minute. United got themselves back on terms early in the second half though, marauding right back Mike Duxbury’s persistence paying off as his ball into the box was smashed into the roof of the net by a sliding Stapleton. Wilkins gave United the lead soon after, hitting Brighton on the break, he cut inside onto his left foot before curling a shot into the top corner from just outside of the box. But with just 3 minutes to go the Seagulls found an equaliser themselves, the ball falling at the feet of centre back Gary Stevens who made it 2-2. Brighton could have, and should have, won the whole thing. With the famous words “and Smith must score”, which later became the name of the south coast clubs’ fanzine, being excitedly spoken by the commentator, it was United’s keeper Bailey who rushed out in the final minute of extra time to deny Smith a famous winner, taking the match to a replay. The following Thursday saw an impressive 91,000 make the repeat trip to Wembley for an evening replay, but with a vastly different outcome.

Brighton took the game to United once more, with a flurry of early shots saved by the impressive Bailey in goal. But the passing up of these chances was punished after 25 minutes when Captain Marvel, British football’s most expensive player, Bryan Robson, with the famous number 7 on his back, lashed a left foot shot home from 25 yards.  Just 4 minutes later, Norman Whiteside capped off an astonishing 12 months which had seen him play at the 1982 World Cup aged just 17 as well as scoring a League Cup Final winner at Wembley against Liverpool, doubling United’s lead in the 29th minute. With Robson tapping in his second and United’s third goal of the match, the Reds were out of sight before half time. And with the only “foreign” player on the pitch, Dutchman Arnold Muhren, calmly slotting home a penalty, Ron Atkinson’s men secured the biggest FA Cup final scoreline for 80 years, a convincing 4-0 victory to give Manchester United yet another trophy.

United line-up: Gary Bailey, Mike Duxbury, Kevin Moran, Gordon McQueen, Arthur Albiston, Alan Davies, Ray Wilkins, Bryan Robson, Arnold Muhren, Frank Stapleton, Norman Whiteside.

Paul Speller

CASEMIRO: master of the dark arts?

Is the Man United man targeted or does he have a disciplinary problem?

As Manchester United bypassed Brighton in the semi-finals of the FA Cup at Wembley to stage an all-Manchester final, Casemiro was key to his side’s fortunes.

Playing in his favoured deep-lying defensive midfield position, the Brazilian overcame a relatively below-par first-half performance by his exceptionally high standards to produce a towering display in the second half as well as extra time.

Casemiro, who in a show of gallant leadership volunteered to take the first penalty in the ensuing shootout, also made no mistake from the spot as he guided his effort beyond a diving Robert Sanchez.

However, an all-too-similar problem reared its ugly head again – Casemiro’s disciplinary record.

The 31-year-old was booked during the opening 45 minutes for a foul on Brighton’s Alexis Mac Allister. Casemiro’s booking was his 11th for the season in all competitions.

No other player in England’s top flight has accumulated more bookings that the United number 18. In his impressive debut season at Old Trafford, the former Real Madrid star has also picked up two red cards (at the time of writing).

At Wembley against the Seagulls, Casemiro’s early booking meant that he walked a tightrope all game, and he did so successfully. He only committed one foul after the warning despite being a defensive colossus in the middle of the park.

While United fans would have been thankful that the Brazil international kept a cool head and stayed in the game, questions remain over Casemiro’s disciplinary record. Is he simply unable to avoid being on the wrong end of refereeing decisions, or does he have a target on his back?

Spanish publication Sport notes that during the eight years he played for Real Madrid, the midfielder was never sent off as a result of a straight red card. The ex-Madridista was only ever given his marching orders twice while at the Santiago Bernabeu, on both occasions for two yellows.

Sport reveals on these two previous incidents in Spain, “The first was during Real Valladolid – Real Madrid on matchday 27 of La Liga during the 2018-2019 season after having committed a total of 308 fouls. It was for a double yellow (the second card for hindering a free kick).”

“The second was on April 10, 2021, in a Madrid-Barça match. Casemiro was shown yellow in the 89th minute for cutting off a counter by Messi and the second, a minute later, for a tough tackle on Mingueza. The game was 2-1 for los Blancos before the sending off and that’s how it ended.”

Is Casemiro at fault for his record in England, or is he is simply an unlucky victim of poor officiating? The truth lies somewhere in between. While referees have made a number of dubious decisions that have seen Casemiro go into the book, the midfielder’s temperament and lack of composure in some instances do not help his cause.

Andre Marriner’s decision to prematurely end Casemiro’s involvement in proceedings against Crystal Palace back in February for a perceived altercation with Will Hughes was nothing short of a disgraceful decision. Despite the fact that Marriner and the VAR officials enjoyed the benefit of video technology and numerous camera angles, he deemed the United man to have had his hands around Hughes’s neck during a heated scrap between United and Palace stars.

Numerous videos of the incident later emerged on social media that discounted the referee’s thinking of the matter.

Ten Hag blasted the decision to send off Casemiro at the time. The seething Dutchman told reporters after the game, “I see two teams fighting each other. I see two teams where several players crossed the line, and one player is picked out and gets sent off. For me, that’s not right.”

“Casemiro is protecting our player and also protecting the player who wants to attack. He is holding him back – he is protecting him. He doesn’t want to hurt him.”

Against Southampton in March, Casemiro was shown red again for a high-challenge tackle on Carlos Alcaraz. The result of his sending-off was he instantly became ineligible for the Red Devils’ next four domestic games against Fulham, Newcastle, Brentford and Everton. This time, it was Anthony Taylor who showed Casemiro red after initially brandishing a yellow card. After conducting a review on the pitchside monitor, Taylor revised his decision.

Like the first time, Ten Hag made no secret of his displeasure with the constant targeting of his team’s midfield general.

“Casemiro played over 500 games in Europe and never once got a red card,” Ten Hag remarked. “Now he has two in the Premier League. His absence is not the issue. We will deal with that. This game was influenced by the referee.”

Former Liverpool star Graeme Souness insisted a few months back that Casemiro is a targetted figure amongst referees and it is hard to argue against this conclusion.

Nevertheless, some of Casemiro’s bookings, especially yellow cards, have been consequences of his own making. His record in Spain was set while playing for a team that was the best in the world most of the time, in a league where the standard is generally lower, and the pace of the game slower, than the Premier League. Simply put, he has to adapt and no longer enjoys the same freedoms.

For Casemiro, his greatest task now lies in cultivating a clean reputation and dispelling the notion that he is a master of the dark arts. His teammates can help in this regard. They must shoulder more defensive responsibilities and drastically reduce the number of times the five-time Champions League winner is required to come up with game-saving interventions.

In the same vein as he did against Brighton, Casemiro must also endeavour to cut out delving into reckless tackles and duels that only serve to place him in awkward situations with referees.

Ten Hag will undoubtedly also try to dissuade referees from targetting his main man. The United boss has already proven that he is not beyond publicly calling out injustice levelled at his players.

Derick Kinoti

eckers

Does money make you happy?

How important is the luxury of laughing at our closest rivals? From singing songs about how it feels to be small to hanging a banner dedicated to 35 years of failure off the Stretford End, it’s been a constant between the two Manchester clubs since the 70s. It might have been a mere sidenote beside decades of on-pitch success but there’s no doubt that revelling in the Blues’ perpetual failings was always an ingredient in United’s special sauce.

To a generation of younger fans, the suspect whiff of baked-in failure no longer encircles our cross-town rivals. They’re a gleaming paragon of success these days – an Apple store that nobody realises is built on a burial ground.The kids probably don’t know that Steve Coppell spent just 33 days at Maine Road before thinking, “Fuck this!” and promptly leaving. Nor are they likely to spare much thought for Forward-With-Franny, the movement that wasn’t.

On the flipside, if you pushed a 90’s Red into a Delorean, they certainly wouldn’t recognise the modern iteration of grubby little city that was waiting for them in 2023. They might reasonably come to the conclusion that a sneaky Blue had slipped back in time to hand Peter Swales a copy of the Sporting Almanac. Weirdly, this explanation would contain an essential truth in that everything they’ve achieved has been handed to them rather than earned. They’re the hapless ne’er do well that won the lottery, bought the entire street and turned into everything they purported to hate.

Which brings us, in a roundabout way, to the fate of United’s identity. We’re slowly creeping towards a crossroads in our long, storied history. For some, Qatar ownership means compensating for the lost moral high ground by having so much money thrown at the club that success becomes inevitable. For others, it would be our turn to sacrifice a decades’ long identity to become a hollow meta-club that doesn’t need to work for anything anymore. The football equivalent of turning into a piano-toothed, botox-blasted LA housewife.

Identities aren’t fixed, they’re a work in progress. So what would we become if the Qataris took over the club? An optimistic reading might be that we’d be us but on steroids. We’d probably be seen as less plastic than the likes of city and PSG by virtue of not having been plucked from obscurity. Plus, we’ll still have reservations about the owners, we’ll still have the same shared history, and we’d mostly be the same fans singing the same songs. Basically we’ll still be United in all the ways that count.

A contradictory viewpoint is that we’d forever be tarnished. Like city before us, we’d become overnight that which we claim to despise. In our case, the slick public face of a sportswashing project. The values of integrity, hard work, toiling for something that isn’t inevitable, would be lost. We’d stop being old money and trade everything that makes us unique for something sterile, bland and new. Who cares how much we might win when every single trophy is instantly cheapened by the ownership?

For all their grits teeth superb football, there’s something unreal about the Blues. They’re a team for the age of ChatGPT. Pep might have created one of the slickest football machines English football has ever seen but the football is forever at odds with the background narrative about inflated accounting and deceit. There’s little sense of jeopardy beyond what’s happening off the pitch. While there’s no saying United would be run so suspiciously, at least our victories mean something. How could anyone trade that?

The alternative is Ratcliffe. He might not be perfect but at least he seems to understand his boyhood club. Yes, there are doubts about keeping the Glazers onboard in any capacity but, honestly, who cares about minority shareholders? Let them have a backseat as long as they can’t get at the wheel. Ratcliffe might not have the PR smarts to promise the world on a stick but even that makes his bid seem more tethered to the real world.

Ultimately, United don’t need a sugar daddy with bottomless pockets – we need to be run as sensibly as the overachieving mid-table clubs like Brighton and Brentford. A well-run United, targeting the right players, hiring the best scouts, coaches and staff would challenge anyone, anywhere. Liverpool didn’t need Middle Eastern owners to compete. They just needed to be efficient and find the right manager to lead the charge.

So ignore the promise of limitless riches. Forget the mocked up fan photos of a new Old Trafford. Don’t announce Mbappe. Let’s retain what makes us great and stay a proper football club. That way we can challenge city the proper way and earn the right to laugh at them.

Scott Eckersley

Top 10 Videos

Some of the best United-related videos on Youtube since the last match

DAVID DE GEA: GROUNDHOG DAY

We’ve been here before with United’s number one

Life with David de Gea has always been full of contradictions. He remains, alongside Cristiano Ronaldo, the player who has won the Sir Matt Busby Player of the Year award the most times (four). Last month, he overtook the legendary Alex Stepney to become the goalkeeper with the most appearances in the history of the club (540).

And against the odds, this season he has won the Premier League Golden Glove, awarded to the goalkeeper who kept the most clean sheets in a season. He has 16 of those at the time of writing. He is the world’s best paid goalkeeper and reportedly has already been offered a deal by United that would keep him in the world’s top five best paid, despite turning 33 later this year.

But there has always been an underbelly.

Fill in the blanks:

Manchester United goalkeeper, David de Gea, was ‘inconsolable’ after his howler saw xxx progress to the semi-finals of the xxx League, apologising to his teammates.

Sevilla, Europa? In fact it was Barcelona, Champions. It was April 2019 and De Gea had allowed a scuffed shot from Lionel Messi to dribble into the net. It was also a month that saw United fall apart in the Premier League and let a comfortable cushion in fourth place slip. De Gea made mistakes against Everton, Man City, Chelsea and Huddersfield Town in that run-in, costing his team 11 points out of the final 15. He was not the only culprit in that episode of football hari-kari, but he was the main one.

There is still a myth, perpetuated by the media and pundits, that De Gea is still one of the world’s best shot stoppers and that his distribution is the only weakness in his game. Yet he has made the joint most mistakes leading to a goal (four at time of writing) in the Premier League this season, and his errors are coming thick and fast again, just as they did in 2018/19.

Louis van Gaal controversially dropped the Spaniard at the start of the 2015-16 season, because he believed his focus was on a potential move to Real Madrid. Fast forward to June of the same year, and despite the abysmal performances that cost United a place in the Champions League semi-final and a place in the following year’s competition, the Spaniard was awarded that lucrative £375,000 a week, five-year contract.

It was a ludicrous decision by the idiotic executive vice chairman at the time, Ed Woodward. He gave an out-of-form keeper a 50% pay increase that took him from being the world’s highest-paid keeper to being by far the world’s highest-paid keeper.

And if you’re wondering if that faith was rewarded by a newly focused, confident De Gea, the answer is that it was not, and he was making howlers again at the start of 2019/20, including one against Crystal Palace’s Jordan Ayew that is etched into the memory of many a despondent United fan. Another against Watford’s Ismaila Sarr sticks in the memory for all the wrong reasons.

At the national level, Spain have long since disposed of De Gea’s services because they realised he was prone to costly errors, including ones in the 2018 World Cup. His famous howler in failing to stop a Cristiano Ronaldo shot in that competition has gone down in folklore, he failed to keep a clean sheet in the competition and pre-tournament third favourites Spain were knocked out in the round of 16 by Russia after he failed to save a penalty in the shootout – or the one in real time.

Which brings us to a certain Europa League final penalty shootout, when he failed to save any of 11 penalties and then missed his own.

After a recent De Gea error against West Ham, Marcus Rashford was snapped looking disdainfully at Erik ten Hag.

It’s easy to read his expression as “how many more times, boss?”, which of course, might not be what he was thinking at all. But, let’s face it, it’s what we’re all thinking. It’s what Freud called “projection”.Time will tell whether this new deal, reportedly “very very close”, is agreed, and if so how much it’s for. I don’t want to do a hatchet job on a man who has saved United countless points over the years and I am grateful for the good times. De Gea is not my scapegoat for a poor run-in that has been brought about by lack of transfer funds, poor finishing, injuries and suspensions and a gruelling schedule, among other things.

But I want my club to be successful and I cannot see it being so as long as its last line of defence is so unreliable. It’s not just about the dodgy distribution, although that alone should be enough of a reason to replace him as it puts us at a serious disadvantage in controlling games and maintaining possession. Enough is enough where De Gea is concerned. We have been here way too many times.

Red Billy

twitter chatter

Some of the best United-related posts on Twitter since the last match

Clicking on a video tweet will open it in Twitter in a new window.

blast from the past

An A-Z of former Players
Tony dunne

Years at club: 1960-1973
535 appearances, 2 goals
Republic of Ireland: 33 caps, 0 goals

His ability goes without saying. We didn’t know much about world football in those days but anyone in that era would say he was the best left back in Europe, without doubt.” – Fellow 1968 European Cup Winner, Brian Kidd.

Early life:
Tony Dunne was born in Dublin in 1941, playing for youth team Stella Maris before signing for Irish giants Shelbourne straight from school in 1958, aged 16.

Before United:
Dunne played for Shelbourne for 2 seasons and had already met with Matt Busby and agreed to sign for Manchester United before going on to win the Irish FA Cup in 1960, leaving for Old Trafford that summer for a fee of £5000.

Manchester United career:
Tony Dunne made his debut for United in October 1960 and played regularly for the first 2 seasons despite being signed primarily only as cover for more experienced players. Dunne was a tough tackling left back, quick and ferocious in the tackle, yet somehow always seemed to evade serious injury. He became a regular by 1963 and was part of the United team that won the FA Cup that year as well as the First Division titles in both 1965 and 1967, before featuring in the European Cup win of 1968. Dunne went on to play a total of 535 times for United, leaving in 1973 as the clubs 3rd highest appearance maker behind only Bobby Charlton and Bill Foulkes.

After United:
Dunne left United in 1973, and made it quite clear that he was unhappy with the club’s treatment of him after 13 years service. Opting to join Bolton, the Irishman went on to make almost 200 appearances for them, retiring in 1979 after a brief stint at Detroit Express in America.

Where are they now:
Dunne settled in Manchester after his career in football, running a driving range in Altrincham. After deciding to sell all of his career medals at auction in 2011 for family reasons, the Manchester United museum purchased them for £44,000. Anthony Peter Dunne sadly passed away on 8th June 2020.

Paul Speller

mystery MancS

Who are these three Man United stars, winning the FA Cup? Click the button to reveal the right answer.

mystery mancs 44-min

jigsaw

Drag the pieces below to solve this United jigsaw.  The default jigsaw has 80 pieces but you can change this by clicking the ‘Play On Jigsawplanet’ button and selecting a different size (opens in new window, no sign in necessary).

Crossword


1. Lost to United in both 1977 and 1983 Cup finals
2. Former Chelsea man, scored for United in 1983 final
3. Captained Newcastle to defeat in 1999 Final
4. Managed the Crystal Palace team who lost to United in 2016 final
5. Scored for Palace in the 2016 final
6. Scored United's first in the 2016 final
7. Scored United's second in the 2016 final
8. Scored United's first in 2004 final
9. Milwall's player manager in 2004 final, also captained losing 1994 finalists
10. Kept goal for United in 2004 final
11. Losing finalists in 1996 final
12. United's goalscorer in 1996 final
13. Playermanager for losing finalists in 1994
14. Scored for United in both 1990 and 94 finals
15. Scored twice for the losing finalists in 1990 final
16. Scored the winning goal in the 1990 replay
17. Opposition goalkeeper who let in 3 for United in 1963
18. Scored a brace for United in 1963 final
19. Kept goal for United in 1963 final
20. Scored only goal in 1985 final

word search

Find the names and words relating to this week’s match in the grid below. They can read left to right, right to left, top to bottom, bottom to top but not diagonally. Drag the cursor along the word to select it. It will be crossed out if you got it right.

united women's world

FA CUp final heartbreak

Manchester United Women suffered heartbreak on their trip to Wembley as Chelsea beat them 1-0 in their FA Cup Final. Despite United never having beaten Chelsea, they headed into the final full of confidence, they are having the best season since they reformed in 2018. They had had a dominant run in the cup leading up to the final, they beat Sunderland 2-1 in the fourth round, Durham 5-0 to progress to the Quarters, Lewes 3-1 and then Brighton 3-2 in a thrilling semi-final match at Leigh Sports Village.

The Reds were in fine form and thought they had scored after just 27 seconds with a superb strike from Leah Galton but it was ruled out for a marginal offside in the build up. United were dominant in possession and made some good runs but they headed in at half-time all square. Unfortunately it was a strike from Sam Kerr, who United had managed to keep quiet for the most part, that was the difference at the end of the 90.

Marc Skinner caused some controversy as he threw away his runner’s up medal and made his team stand together and watch Chelsea celebrate with the trophy despite many feeling exhausted and distraught. However, Skinner said it was important that his players used it as fuel going forward.

WSL PROGRESS

This past week (at time of writing), Chelsea then caught up and overtook United in the league table as they won their games in hand. At the time of publication, United could still win the league but it relies on other teams. United would need to win their remaining two games against City and Liverpool and hope that Chelsea lost one of their two games. If Chelsea drew one of theirs, the two teams would be level on points but Chelsea have just overtaken United on goal difference.

However, despite the disappointment in the FA Cup Final and the Reds being knocked off the top of their perch in the run-in to the end of the season, it has still been a successful campaign. Champions League football is all but guaranteed, to miss out now would mean the Reds losing their last two games and City taking an 18 goal swing. Therefore, for the first time since their reformation United look to be playing European football in the 23/24 season. This was of course their main goal this season and Reds fans are ecstatic as they dust off their passports!

Whatever happens, United have played some thrilling football, creating so many memorable moments for the players and fans alike. There has been a massive shift in mentality this year which is evident from the comebacks and last minute goals that have got points on the board where we previously would have given them up or settled for a draw. The first obvious game where you could see that shift was the Arsenal game at the Emirates which will live long in the memory of the fans. They went ahead in the first half courtesy of Ella Toone before Arsenal scored two quick goals at the start of the second half. Millie Turner then levelled in the 84th minute before Alessia Russo made it 3-2 in injury time.

A 0-0 draw looked certain at Reading but Rachel Williams came off the bench on that Occasion and dug deep to get a late winner. Meanwhile, at Aston Villa away, United twice fell behind to goals from Rachel Daly. The Reds responded both times but in the 93rd minute it looked like the league leaders at the time would have to settle for a point. Millie Turner, an 84th minute substitute rose higher than anyone to head in a Katie Zelem free-kick to keep their title hopes alive.

Even in the less dramatic games, the Reds have played impressive and entertaining football; 3-0 up against Tottenham at home and United were being ruthless and relentless in their attacks. The quick link up play and one touch football was breathtaking to watch. It’s almost cruel to think that these players won’t receive any tangible reward for the season they have had, ask any United fan and they will tell you they have spent the season beaming with joy, pride and excitement. The Reds also have the highest attendances in the league and it’s not surprising to see why.

transfer speculation

So with the prospect of European football next season on the cards, what can Reds fans expect in the transfer window? Well, as most will know Ona Batlle, arguably the Reds best player this season looks set to leave, she will be the greatest loss for the Reds and it will be difficult to replace her. Alessia Russo is also still in contract talks with the club, but I have a feeling she may choose to stay. Vile Boe Risa is staying at the club after United triggered her one year extension. However, many doors have been opened and barriers broken down this season and United will attract more high profile players from across the globe.

In terms of incomings, there are strong rumours that United are poised to sign free agent Maitane López Millán, a Spain international.

Zoe Hodges

HERO to ZERO

Who are we raving about this week?

Hero

VICTOR LINDELOF

Boy he’s had some stick over the years but what a performance at Wembley in the semi-final and that gutsy penalty to take us through? Bravo 👏🏻

ZERO

david de gea

Another penalty shootout without a single save from De Gea. He moves way too soon, it’s painful to watch. Luckily Solly March skied his pen otherwise it’s hard to believe we’d have been in the final.

RED billy

More important than a striker or a new owner, and Ten Hag is screaming it

I don’t remember a time when United were such underdogs as they will be in the FA Cup final. At the time of writing, City are an incredible 4/11 and United 2/1 for the outright win.

It begs the question, whatever the outcome of the game on June 3rd, how do United close that gap?

Many people argue that City have bought their success and are bankrolled to a level that United can only dream of. Yet in reality, United’s net spend in the last five years (cost of transfers minus money made from player sales) is more than double that of City. United’s has been £540.23 million whereas City’s has been £224.97m. United have bought unwisely and sold badly. It’s not that they’ve had less money than their neighbours in their transfer budget.

This brings me to comments that Erik ten Hag made at a recent press conference.

Asked whether he agrees that the most important person at a football club is the manager, such as Sir Alex Ferguson or Pep Guardiola at Man City, Ten Hag replied:

“I don’t know if that is true. About City, [director of football, [Txiki] Begiristain does a very…”

He was then interrupted by the reporter saying ‘That club is built for Pep Guardiola’, but he insisted: “Yes but I think still, don’t underestimate the role of Begiristain.”

Laurie Whitwell of The Athletic concluded that “His repeated insistence on recognising the work of Begiristain felt telling.”

Unlike every other top club in the world, Manchester United, until recently, have continued to operate without a director of football. One was finally appointed in March 2021, John Murtough, but the appointment was met with skepticism as it was an internal appointment of a friend of the then executive vice chairman, Ed Woodward. Murtough, incredibly, was someone with no previous experience as a DoF appointed to probably the biggest and most difficult DoF job in the world.

Many, including Gary Neville, saw it as the appointment of a “yes man” to Woodward and the Glazers rather than a genuine effort by the family to fill this crucial role. Along with the appointment of a sidekick technical director, whatever that is, in Darren Fletcher, Murtough’s appointment was clearly a case of jobs for the boys.

Fast forward two years and Murtough is now faced with unprecedented transfer budget uncertainty as the club tries to fill crucial and expensive gaps in the United side in a summer window with no knowledge of who will be in charge and what the budget will be. He might be a great chap and I don’t pretend to know all the ins and outs of what makes up a DoF’s day, but I would argue, this man is simply not qualified to do the job. And Ten Hag’s comments, I would also argue, were a sign of him silently screaming this fact out to anyone whose ears were sharp enough to pick it up.

There are unquestionably elite options available, or becoming available. Liverpool’s former sporting director, the man responsible for finding talent such as Mo Salah for the club, Michael Edwards is currently unemployed. As reported here this week, FC Barcelona’s Jordi Cruyff, a former United player, is also set to leave the Blaugrana this summer.

So many people are saying United are a top striker and top midfielder away from closing the gap on City. But the ability to get that top striker and top midfielder – the right ones at the right price – is a pre-requisite if United want to make that happen. Not to mention the next signing, and the one after. I don’t know about you, but I’m bracing myself for another summer filled with a painful, drawn out “will he, won’t he?” saga as we have seen with the likes of Erling Haaland, Jadon Sancho and Frenkie de Jong.

The simple fact is that the lack of a top-notch director of football is the biggest reason for United’s lack of success on the pitch since Sir Alex left. I want the Glazers out as much as the next person and I want an Osimhen or Kane or a De Jong as much as the next person. But Ten Hag’s comments hint at what is more important to United’s future success than anything else – and that is a top of the range, fit-for-purpose director of football.

FIXTURES, RESULTS & LEAGUE TABLE

© United Matchday Magazine, all rights reserved. 

Number 44 FA Cup Final
May 20, 2023

WELCOME

To read the magazine, simply scroll down, or click the down arrow at the top of any page to bring up the table of contents:

This issue will be updated every morning until match day and after the manager’s press conference. You can see the date it was last updated on the magazine’s footer.

Answer, left to right: Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Roy Keane, Mikael Silvestre. Well done if you got it right!

1. Case 2. Wilkins 3. Shearer 4. Pardew 5. Puncheon 6. Mata 7. Lingard 8. Ronaldo 9. Wise 10. Howard 11. Liverpool 12. Cantona 13. Hoddle 14. Hughes 15. Wright 16. Martin 17. Banks 18. Herd 19. Gaskell 20. Whiteside